How Plea Bargains Work in Wyoming Criminal Cases
If you’ve been charged with a crime, your attorney might be able to arrange a plea deal that offers certain advantages, such as reduced penalties, avoiding trial, or the dismissal or reduction of charges against you. It’s essential to find a Wyoming criminal defense lawyer who will go over your options and clearly explain the risks and advantages of choosing or rejecting a plea agreement.
At Steven Titus & Associates, P.C., we’ve successfully guided clients through the Wyoming criminal courts. In this guide, we’ll break down everything you need to know about plea deals in Wyoming, from how they’re negotiated to the pros and cons of choosing a plea over trial.
What Is a Plea Bargain?
A criminal plea agreement is a deal between a defendant and the prosecution. In exchange for a guilty or no-contest plea, the prosecution agrees to reduce the charges, recommend a lighter sentence, or dismiss some counts altogether.
The overwhelming majority of criminal cases in Wyoming and nationwide are resolved through plea agreements instead of going to trial. But that doesn’t mean these deals are always the best choice for a defendant.
The Plea Bargain Process in Wyoming
Initial Charges and Arraignment
After arrest, you’ll be formally charged and brought to court for an arraignment, where you’ll be asked to enter a plea (guilty, not guilty, or no contest). Your attorney may recommend waiting to enter a plea until you’ve reviewed all the evidence.
Discovery and Case Evaluation
Your defense team reviews police reports, witness statements, videos, and other evidence. An experienced Wyoming criminal defense team like Steven Titus & Associates, P.C. will assess the strength of the case against you, identify possible defenses, and evaluate potential plea deals.
Sentencing Negotiation
If your attorney determines a plea deal might be in your best interest, they can enter sentencing negotiations with the prosecutor. This could involve reducing a felony to a misdemeanor, agreeing to probation instead of jail, or avoiding certain penalties (like sex offender registration or driver’s license suspension).
Reaching an Agreement
Once both sides agree, the terms are put in writing. However, even after signing, a Wyoming judge must approve the plea before it becomes final.
Judicial Oversight Is Required
Under Rule 11 of the Wyoming Rules of Criminal Procedure, the judge must ensure that your plea is:
- Voluntary
- Intelligent
- Based on a factual basis
This means the judge will ask you questions in court to confirm that:
- You understand the charges and consequences.
- You weren’t forced or promised anything inappropriate.
- You’re mentally competent to enter a plea.
The judge has discretion to accept or reject the plea deal, particularly if they believe the sentence is too lenient or the plea isn’t supported by the facts.
Types of Pleas in Wyoming
Guilty Plea
The defendant admits to the offense and accepts responsibility. This plea is often used when the evidence is strong or when a favorable deal is on the table.
No Contest Plea (Nolo Contendere)
The defendant does not admit guilt but accepts the conviction and punishment. This plea is useful in cases where a guilty plea might be used against the defendant in civil lawsuits (like after an assault).
Pros and Cons of Accepting a Plea Deal
Every plea offer must be evaluated in context: your criminal history, the strength of the case, and what’s at stake long-term. Your attorney’s job is to give you the information and legal support you need to make the right choice for your situation.
Benefits of a Plea Deal
- Reduced Charges: A felony could be dropped to a misdemeanor, or multiple counts consolidated.
- Lighter Sentence: Avoiding jail time or getting probation.
- Predictability: No risk of the unknowns at trial.
- Faster Resolution: Ending the case sooner, reducing stress and legal costs.
- Sealing Options: Some plea deals may allow for expungement later.
Risks of a Plea Deal
- Criminal Record: You still end up with a conviction.
- Waiving Trial Rights: You give up the right to challenge the evidence in court.
- Immigration Consequences: For non-citizens, even a minor conviction can lead to deportation.
- Future Penalties: A plea can be used as a prior conviction in future charges.
What If You Reject the Plea?
If you turn down a plea offer, your case proceeds to trial. This can be a bench trial (heard by a judge) or a jury trial. If convicted at trial, you could face harsher sentencing. If acquitted, you walk away free of any criminal conviction.
Special Considerations in Wyoming Plea Cases
Misdemeanor Plea Deals
Plea agreements for misdemeanors often involve:
- Deferred adjudication (with conditions)
- Time served or minimal fines
- Community service
Felony Charges
Felony cases require more complex negotiation. For example, your Wyoming criminal defense attorney may fight for charge reductions to avoid sex offender registration, firearm bans, or lifetime consequences.
Probation Violations
If you’re accused of violating probation, you may face a new plea negotiation. This is another critical moment when having a seasoned Wyoming criminal defense attorney matters.
What Makes a Good Plea Deal?
Plea negotiations are high-stakes decisions that can define your future. A plea deal should be negotiated considering the following:
- Your chances of winning at trial
- The weight of the evidence
- Your personal background and goals
- Collateral consequences (like job loss or housing restrictions)
Speak With a Trusted Criminal Defense Attorney in Campbell County Today
At Steven Titus & Associates, P.C., we treat every case like it’s going to trial. That level of preparation puts us in the strongest position to negotiate a pela arrangement on your behalf or take your case to court.
Call us today at (307) 257-7800 to schedule a free consultation.
Whether you’re facing a tough prosecutor or weighing the risk of trial, we’re ready to help you make the right call.
Your FREE Case Strategy Session
On All Injury and Criminal Cases
Contact our office right now to speak to
someone who wants to help you.