Legal Blog
blog home Personal Injury How Long-Term Scarring Affects Personal Injury Settlements in Gillette, WY

How Long-Term Scarring Affects Personal Injury Settlements in Gillette, WY

By Steven Titus & Associates, P.C. on August 29, 2025

Person with their hand placed above scar on their upper back.

In a personal injury case, it’s easy to focus on immediate injuries like broken bones or hospital bills. But long after a wound has healed, visible scars can leave lasting physical, emotional, and financial marks that impact the victim’s life.

For residents of Gillette and people across Wyoming, understanding how long-term scarring influences a personal injury settlement is essential to recovering fair compensation.

Compensatory Damages in Wyoming

In a personal injury claim or lawsuit, Wyoming emphasizes compensatory damages, which are awards intended to make the injured party whole again.

Securing a fair settlement requires quantifying the actual harm: physical pain, emotional distress, and loss of enjoyment of life. That includes the effects of long-term or permanent scarring, especially when the scar is located on highly visible parts of the body like the face, neck, or hands.

What Are Non-Economic Damages?

Non-economic damages refer to the intangible consequences of an injury. These damages are subjective, but that doesn’t make them any less important. In fact, courts in Wyoming often treat non-economic harm like long-term scarring damages as highly significant in calculating the overall injury settlement.

In Gillette personal injury cases, this may include:

  • Pain and suffering
  • Emotional trauma
  • Anxiety or depression related to disfigurement
  • Reduced quality of life
  • Social withdrawal or embarrassment
  • Impact on romantic relationships or social acceptance

How Do Courts Evaluate Permanent Scarring?

There’s no fixed formula to determine the value of scarring in a personal injury case. However, several injury settlement factors influence how much a scar might increase the overall compensation.

Location of the Scar

Scars on visible or prominent areas such as the face, neck, or arms generally command higher compensation than those in concealed areas like the torso or legs.

Juries may be especially sympathetic to individuals who suffer disfigurement that affects their ability to engage confidently in social life or public-facing employment.

Size and Severity

A minor scar from a small cut may not significantly affect a settlement. But deep, raised, or irregular scarring that alters the skin’s texture, requires revision surgeries, or causes recurring pain can result in a much higher award.

Impact on Employment or Social Life

If the scar impairs your ability to work—especially in careers where appearance matters—this can dramatically raise the value of the claim. Likewise, evidence that the scarring has impacted your relationships or mental health can strengthen your case.

Age and Gender of the Victim

While every individual experiences trauma differently, younger victims and women have historically received higher awards for cosmetic injuries due to presumed longer-term emotional consequences. Judges and juries may consider life expectancy and anticipated psychological toll when evaluating personal injury claims.

Building a Strong Case for Damages

If you’re seeking compensation for long-term scarring after an accident in Gillette, your legal strategy must clearly establish the scar’s effect on your life. Here are a few ways Steven Titus & Associates, P.C., builds a compelling argument:

  • Photographic Evidence: Before-and-after photos help juries visualize the impact of the scarring.
  • Medical Testimony: Doctors can speak to the permanence of the scar, treatment history, and likelihood of improvement.
  • Psychological Evaluations: A licensed counselor can document emotional trauma, anxiety, or depression linked to the scarring.
  • Vocational Experts: In cases where the injury affects job performance, vocational experts may testify about lost income potential.

Insurance Companies and Scarred Clients

Insurers are not known for generosity. In cases involving cosmetic injuries, they often attempt to minimize the emotional or psychological harm caused by disfigurement.

Hoping to reduce the settlement, insurance companies may argue that the scarring is “purely cosmetic” and not functionally disabling. However, the psychological and social toll of permanent scarring is very real.

If you try to handle the negotiation alone, you may leave significant compensation on the table. Our Campbell County law firm will not be swayed by these underhanded tactics. In fact, we push back against lowball offers.

At Steven Titus & Associates, P.C., we know how to quantify and present evidence that highlights the personal impact of your injury and how to navigate Wyoming’s legal framework to pursue the settlement you deserve.

Time Limits and Documentation

Wyoming has a statute of limitations of four years for most personal injury claims. It’s important to remember that waiting too long to file could jeopardize your case. Over time, witness memories fade, documentation can be lost, and the defense may argue that the injury wasn’t as severe as claimed.

Steven Titus & Associates, P.C., will investigate the accident and help you gather and organize the necessary documentation to support your claim, which may include:

  • All medical visits
  • Surgical consultations
  • Mental health therapy related to disfigurement
  • Photographs documenting the healing process
  • Communications with employers about work-related impacts

Why Local Representation Matters

In a close-knit community like Gillette, every personal injury case is local. Judges, jurors, and insurers alike have unique expectations and attitudes shaped by Wyoming’s conservative values and legal limits on damages. That’s why hiring a law firm with deep roots in the region is so important.

Steven Titus & Associates, P.C., is based right here in Gillette. We understand local norms and how to present your case to maximize your credibility and compensation. Whether your scarring came from a vehicle collision, dog bite, workplace accident, or another traumatic incident, we can guide you every step of the way.

Schedule a Free Consultation Today

If you or a loved one has been left with long-term scarring from an accident in Gillette, don’t allow the insurance company to define your worth! Permanent scars do more than alter your appearance—they can alter your identity, your future, and your sense of self.

Let Steven Titus & Associates, P.C., help you tell your story and fight for the justice you deserve. Call (307) 257-7800 to schedule your free consultation today with our Gillette personal injury lawyer. We’ll evaluate your case, explain your options, and start building a strategy that prioritizes your recovery and your future.

Related Articles:

Posted in: Personal Injury

Steven Titus

Your FREE Case Strategy Session
On All Injury and Criminal Cases

Contact our office right now to speak to
someone who wants to help you.